New $949,900 · 36± Acres

Chenango County

"The Preserve" - 2 Barns, Trout Stream, Woods, Borders NYS Land

1921 County Road 16, Lot#WP002 Plymouth, NY 13832

Description

THIS PROPERTY IS NOT IN A FLOOD ZONE. FEMA MAPS CAN BE PROVIDED. "The Preserve" is an extraordinary home where Adirondack style meets Yellowstone - on 36 +/- acres with 2 barns, grass field, woods, natural pond & feeder trout stream. Built in 2005, this 4896 sq. ft. stick frame home features massive log pillars, 12" half-log western ponderosa pine siding, 4 oversized bedrooms, 6.5 baths, huge dining room, 2 living rooms and a truly gourmet kitchen. An additional 1345 sq. ft. lower level has a workout room, laundry & large bar/rec room for a total of 6241 sq. ft. of living space. Culinary dreams come true in the 400 sq. ft. Chef's Kitchen featuring: 60" Wolf stove with grill, 2 full size ovens & 6 gas burners; 60" Wolf Hood vent, full size stainless shelf with 2 infrared heat lamps; KitchenAid warming drawer, (2) KitchenAid dishwashers, Samsung French door refrigerator; 35 ft of granite counters, custom hickory cabinets & 7x9' walk-in pantry. Entertain in the stunning 17x30' dining room, which eats 30 guests, soaring cathedral ceiling, 3-tier antler chandelier, enormous ponderosa pine beams, floor to ceiling fieldstone fireplace & wall of glass sliders leading to 20x30' Trex covered deck. All 4 bedrooms are oversized, each with its own full bath & individually zoned thermostat for personalized comfort. The primary bedroom has a gas fireplace, 2 separate "his and hers" baths and walk-in closet. Other bespoke features include: locally hand-wrought iron railings, Hickory hardwood flooring as well as Tennessee limestone, Bluestone and Soapstone, custom-cut half log open staircase, fieldstone floor to ceiling see-through gas fireplace made with stones off the farm & hand hewn beam mantel repurposed from the original 1820 farmhouse. Hand-crafted cabinetry including the kitchen and 4 bathrooms from local hickory, cherry and even basswood sourced from the original farmhouse. The finished basement features a 694 sq. ft. rec room with pool table & custom log bar seats 12 with bar sink, wine cooler & bluestone bar top. Both house and barn are newly stained Fall 2025. The natural gas furnace has 9 zones, while the outdoor wood-burning Central Boiler offers inexpensive heating. Other details are copper plumbing, ALL walls & ceilings insulated, Superior poured concrete/insulated foundation, 1500 gallon septic with separate drywell, a 365 ft drilled well with carbon water filtration system & excellent internet service. A restored 3 story barn (1880) & new 50x40' garage/barn (2023) room for 4+ vehicles & a 20x60' extension have power, lighting, water and concrete pad with 2 acre grass field suitable for livestock or horses. Bordering 1043 acres of Otselic State Forest, this property is mostly wooded with a mix of maple, cherry, ash & hemlock, with hiking/RV trails and 1945' of Middletown Brook, a feeder trout stream. With diverse topography, nearby hay fields & multiple water sources, surrounding wild apple trees and native brush providing browse and bedding areas, this property offers ideal opportunity for observing wildlife and outdoor recreation. Within 5 miles, there are 7 more State Forests w/ over 25,000 acres offering hiking, fishing, canoeing, hunting and snowmobiling. More fishing available on the Otselic River 2 miles; Chenango River 14 miles; Whitney Point Reservoir 30 miles & world-class Oneida Lake 44 miles. Golf is available in nearby Norwich 15 miles, Hamilton 18 miles & Turning Stone Resort & Casino 37 miles. Miles of snowmobile trails are accessible nearby, while skiing available at Greek Peak Mountain Resort 37 miles, Labrador Mountain 22 miles & Song Mountain 32 miles. Ithaca and the amazing Finger Lakes Region are just one hour drive west, while world renowned Cooperstown with the National Baseball Hall of Fame, multiple museums, theater and Otsego Lake are one hour to the east. Amenities are nearby within 15 mins, while additonal. restaurants, shopping and entertainment less than an hour: Cortland/Syracuse area 45 mins; Binghamton/Cooperstown/Utica less than 1 hr. NYC/GWB 3.5 hours. *Property is owned by a Real Estate Broker. **More acreage (up to total of 150 acres) is available.


Summary

Address

1921 County Road 16, Lot#WP002

Plymouth, NY 13832

Chenango County

Get Directions

Approximate Distances

15 mins Norwich
45 mins Syracuse
40 mins Cortland
1 hr Binghamton or Utica
3.5 hrs NYC/George Washington Bridge

Property

Property Type
Recreational Land, Residential Land, Hunting Land
Road Frontage
County Road
Road Surface
Pavement
Outbuildings
Metal, Barn, Garage

Land Details

Timber

Tillable

Grass

Pond

Utilities

electric
Onsite
gas
Onsite
sewer
Onsite
internet
Onsite
water
Onsite

Improvements/Features

Small Game, Big Game, Upland Game, Predators, Waterfowl, Fish, Creek/Spring, Trail Network, Seller's Mineral Rights Convey


Details

  • Greek Revival, 4896 sq. ft., stick frame construction with 12" log siding, built in 2005
  • True gourmet kitchen: 60" Wolf Range, 60" Hood with warming lights, KitchenAid warming drawer, 2 KitchenAid dishwashers
  • Four oversized bedrooms with two primaries, all individually zoned and insulated for soundproofing
  • 30' x 17' dining room seats 30, with 3 sliders to 30' x 20' Trex deck
  • Finished lower level custom log bar with bluestone top, seats 12, full size pool table, room card table and TV seating
  • Restored original 1880 two-story barn with full basement & new metal pole barn with oversized garage, power & water
  • Paddock area behind new barn, trails through woodlot, which backs onto NYS Otselic State Forest
  • Feeder trout stream runs 1945 +/- feet within property
  • Area renowned for wildlife conservation, whitetail and wild turkey hunting as well as fishing


Other

Coordinates

42.6754, -75.7121

Annual Taxes

$0

John Myers

Josh Buell

Nearby Related Properties


New
$1,250,000 150 acres ±
Chenango County • Plymouth, NY 13832
For Sale
$119,000 32.59 acres ±
Chenango County • Plymouth, NY 13832
For Sale
$579,000 50.1 acres ±
Chenango County • South Otselic, NY 13155
New
$315,000 1.56 acres ±
Chenango County • South Otselic, NY 13155
For Sale
$99,900 20.24 acres ±
Chenango County • South Otselic, NY 13155
New
$1,199,000 8 acres ±
Chenango County • Smyrna, NY 13464
New
$325,000 1.83 acres ±
Madison County • Hamilton, NY 13346
For Sale
$100,000 5.73 acres ±
Chenango County • Cincinnatus, NY 13040
Stay Connected

Be Part of a Thriving Land Community!

Get the same expert advice, property strategies, and land management tips that thousands of landowners trust. Subscribe now and stay ahead in the market.