We have just completed our 4th transaction over the course of the past 10 years with Jeff Propst in the sale of our Putnam County 467, it was smooth and problem free as usual. I found a Southern Illinois farm that my family fell in love with so I needed to get my Putman property under contract in a hurry and Jeff came through big time. I have known Jeff for many years now and he is a good friend...but as you well know there is a lot of money and moving parts in these farm transactions and I have the necessity for the best of the best when buying and selling land and Jeff is certainly that. I'm just fortunate to call him my friend beyond business.   We look forward to our closing on the Mermet Farm this week via Justin Mason. I have told Jeff many a time that I love Whitetail Properties as a company and brand.  I'm proud to wear my WP gear and enjoy stopping by the office to purchase a new hat or shirt when I work in the Pittsfield area.  Thank you for creating a company that has helped my family create a better life.  

Nick Kramer

I wanted to let you know that working with Whitetail Properties was an enjoyable and stress-free experience. I have bought, sold, and owned various types of real estate since I was in my early 20's, so this wasn't my first rodeo. Through the years, I have seen a lot of good and some bad through those transactions and potential transactions. I met Jeff Propst over the phone 2 years ago and liked him immediately. I have done a ton of big game hunting over the years, so we had a lot in common. The first thing about Jeff is he knows what he is talking about when it comes to deer and deer management.  He's not a BS'er. You can't sell property or anything else consistently unless you know what you're talking about. Jeff always told me the pros and cons about property we looked at and would always give his honest opinion. Aside from his knowledge, his character as a person and his integrity are by far his best assets to your company. Jeff wanted me to make the right decision for me, not just for the sale. NO PRESSURE! He seems like a friend I have known for a long time. I don't know how long I will own this farm, but I know Whitetail Properties will be my first call when I sell it.

Mark Beaudin

Excellent! Excellent reputation.

Dean and Bebe Ellsworth

Jeff was great. He made everything easy for me.

Frank Schaaf

Jeff is a great guy and a true professional. He always answers his phone. We have become great friends. Jeff referred me to Josh when I had a farm to sell in Pa. Josh did a great job and communicated well! I don't like voicemails, it's nice when people pick up the phone like Jeff & Josh do.

Ken Yovich

Jeff and David, we appreciate the hard work of selling our property. I know it was a challenge with the Covid virus. Thank you and good luck selling other properties.

Sharon Hurley

Very professional, can't say enough. In the future it's the only company I will use.

Kenneth Klemm

As you know, Dad and I have talked for years about trying to buy a farm out of state to increase some hunting opportunity’s for us. After we felt like we had got our Indiana farm to reach its full potential, it was time for a new challenge. We were told that if we wanted to find some superb hunting ground you were the man to talk to. It’s a HUGE understatement to say that you didn’t surpass all expectations. The first farm you showed us (not the only farm) but the first farm was the farm we ended up purchasing. It was considerably farther and larger than we were wanting to find but you said if we wanted to have a chance at large whitetails, you believed it to be one of the best farms you had ever seen. Turns out after watching you and Chris all those years on TV, you truly knew what you were talking about. Hahaha. After getting the Cudde back cameras out, the redneck blind trailer stands ready we have since harvested 6 bucks with over a 160” average and a monster 191” buck. We are so excited to see what this farm will produce over the next few years!  Jeff, thanks again for showing us this farm and doing whatever it took to get the deal done and ensure a smooth and clean closing. The memories my dad and I have made on this place so far are the same memories I watched you and Chris make over the years on Drurys and am so thankful to have created and witnessed. I know you get a lot of happiness out of your job, you can hear it every time you talk about it. I hope this brings just a little more of that to you because you truly are a class act with a realistic expectation on land valuations for both the seller and the buyer. At the end of the day in your mind “you are just doing your job” but there are few people in each industry that are at the top of their respective field and we feel you are at the summit my friend. Thanks again for your honesty, support, and friendship at this point. Dad and I truly appreciate it. Whitetail Properties is lucky to have you on board man!

Tony Ardizzone

Worked with David Westmoreland and Jeff Propst. The experience with both of them was very good. I feel they worked with both buyer and seller so that both parties felt like they were treated well.

Tom Olerich

I do want to thank you and Stephen for making the sale as stress free as possible, as selling the land that I grew up on was not easy for me. I would recommend your services to anyone that would ask me.  Keep up the good work.

Jerry Coker